SFWRITER.COM > Novels > Illegal Alien > Review Excerpts
Review Excerpts
Robert J. Sawyer's Illegal Alien
"I don't need to say that Sawyer is good you already know
that. But I can assure you that he hasn't slipped. You'll enjoy
this one."
Analog
"Sawyer's most Asimov-ish book to date. A fast-paced blend of
first contact and whodunit that touches upon a lot of issues and
crams a whole bunch of good old hard-sf speculation into a very
tight plot. A good read."
Bakka Books in-store review
"It's the total business! A cracking courtroom drama and proper
science fiction. No compromises with either element. Ingenious construction,
wholly satisfying!"
K.A. Bedford, Aurealis Award-winning author of Eclipse
"The best aliens since Larry Niven's puppeteers."
Ken Day, CHAY-FM
"If you like Rogue Lawyer by John Grisham, you might like
Illegal Alien by Robert J. Sawyer."
Dayton Daily News (Dayton, Ohio)
"The dust jacket blurb makes the claim that `Robert Sawyer is
Canada's only native-born, full-time, science fiction writer.'
The claim is irrelevant: He sets a standard for writers of any
nationality. Illegal Alien is one of few first-contact novels
that has even a smattering of originality. Sawyer mixes
tongue-in-cheek (although these aliens don't seem to have
tongues or cheeks) humor with courtroom drama and impending
doom for humanity. The result is a tightly written page turner
that satisfies from the start."
Denver Rocky Mountain News
"This is one fine courtroom drama, with enough twists in the plot
to keep any mystery fan flipping the pages; it puts Perry Mason
and John Grisham to shame. The novel is far too good to attempt
to summarize; let's just say that Sawyer delves into all sorts of
strange and wonderful conflicts, including the war between
science and belief, and just what God may or may not be.
Illegal Alien is the best Canadian mystery of 1997."
Margaret Cannon in The Globe and Mail: Canada's National Newspaper
"As always, Sawyer provides crackerjack characters, a fresh
approach and an intelligent, complex plot. Highly recommended."
H. J. Kirchhoff in The Globe and Mail: Canada's National Newspaper
"As gripping as anything encountered by Perry Mason."James Gunn
"An intriguing mix of science fiction, mystery and courtroom
drama."
The Hartford Courant
"Science fiction and suspense mingle as Earth's first alien
visitors become suspects in a murder trial, when expert
worldbuilder Sawyer takes the action to our own planet.
Recommended."
Locus
"Illegal Alien appears to be the first First Contact
courtroom-drama murder mystery. The book offers a detailed
treatment of the court system, from jury selection onward,
wrapped around a Nivenesque alien-nature puzzle. Illegal
Alien offers a genuinely science-fictional Idea story that
should be intelligible to readers outside the SF subculture. It
could be that rare animal, a crossover book that can be enjoyed
on both sides of the great divide."
Locus (again)
"Few novels (science fiction or otherwise) can match Illegal Alien
for imagination and intelligence. Sawyer has created a smart and
satisfying mystery, but he spends more time on the bigger questions.
Why do we tend to presume people are guilty merely because we don't
like them? Why do we often think someone's being standoffish, and fail
to understand that we're making him uncomfortable? And why, for crying
out loud, do we assume that someone who looks different from us can't
possibly, inside, be just like us? Sawyer keeps us distracted by
these rather vital questions, and we're caught looking the other
way when he springs his big surprise at novel's end. But still,
after we've shaken our heads a few times, and caught our breath,
we're left thinking not about a writer's cleverness, but about
ourselves, and how we'd behave if we were one of the story's
characters."
Mystery News
"A fascinating tale that is an eerie parallel to the O.J. Simpson
trial."
The Mystery Review
"Robert Sawyer examines everything from human evolutionary quirks
to racism within the American legal system. The mystery is
carefully constructed to illuminate the differences between the two
species."
New Scientist
"Sawyer skillfully blends courtroom drama with first-contact
science fiction Arthur C. Clarke, meet John Grisham. Sawyer
displays an impressive depth and breadth of both legal and
scientific research his aliens and his lawyers are equally
credible. In its discussion of law and culture, of Tosok
religions and taboos, of the impact of physical circumstances on
biological and social evolution, among many other areas,
Illegal Alien provides us with messages and metaphors that
humanity will have a continuing need to hear. Sawyer suggests
that compassionate idealism (also embodied in the law, at its
best) is what saves species and worlds from falling into
darkness. Ultimately, Illegal Alien is a deeper and more
important novel than its high-concept title and quick-reading,
highly polished, and highly contemporary surface might suggest.
It admirably combines the hard side of science, law, and order
with the softer side of compassion and idealism. As a book that
calls us to think and feel outside our own preconceptions, it is
well worth the thoughtful sf reader's attention."
The New York Review of Science Fiction
"Absorbing. Sawyer carefully underplays everything in this solid
SF version of a legal thriller. The aliens are described in
fascinating detail, and there are several worthwhile mysteries to
be solved."
Publishers Weekly
"A tour de force of intricate, puzzle-like complexity.
Well worth reading for its cleverness, its portrayal of a
fascinating alien race, and its thematic consideration of the
role of philosophical and religious beliefs among rational
beings."
Science Fiction Age
"Some of the best trial scenes in SF, an intriguing mystery,
interesting aliens, and a sinister backplot, all excellently
balanced. Add another hit to Sawyer's string."
Science Fiction Chronicle
"An enjoyable thriller where legal points and jury psychology
matter more than astrophysics. The trial is fascinating: Robert
J. Sawyer obviously enjoys depicting the foibles of American
justice, and lawyer Dale Rice, who is both principled and
unscrupulous, is a fine character. The ending is satisfying and
a clever epilogue will leave readers hoping for a sequel."
Starlog
"Sawyer deals metaphorically with the issue of racism in the
courts, but entertains the reader with sharp wit along with the
heavier themes."
The Nashville Tennessean
"So many science-fiction accolades have been showered on Robert
J. Sawyer that it's all too easy to forget his prizes include an
Arthur Ellis Award from the Crime Writers
of Canada. So it should come as no surprise to find Sawyer's
latest book embracing clues, criminals and cross-examination in
an immensely satisfying whodunit. Pro that he is, Sawyer takes
pains to ensure that everything we need to know about the aliens
is exposed early in the novel and that every piece of info
pointing to the killer is right there in plain sight. And sci-fi
fans should note that Illegal Alien is as much a
true science-fiction novel as it is a mystery."
The Toronto Star
"Innovative, imaginative, and pioneering not just excellent sf
but also excellent popular literature . . . a fast-paced, exciting
book that shows the imaginative heights to which science fiction
writers can climb when they combine sf with something else."
The Washington Post
"Imaginative and enjoyable. Sawyer not only builds up his mystery
masterfully, he also demonstrates a deft sense of humour."
Whitehorse (Yukon) Star
"Blends the world of John Grisham with that of Frederik Pohl or
Larry Niven. Sawyer's skillful use of dialogue moves the case
and the novel briskly along. Illegal Alien has a
lot to offer those who enjoy sophisticated alien / human morality
plays."
The Winnipeg Free Press
More Good Reading
More about Illegal Alien
Robert J. Sawyer's awards and honors
What's a Rob Sawyer novel like?
Review index
My Very Occasional Newsletter
HOME • MENU • TOP
Copyright © 1995-2024 by Robert J. Sawyer.
|