SFWRITER.COM > Novels > Rollback > Review Excerpts
Review Excerpts
Robert J. Sawyer's Rollback
"This is an exciting science fiction thriller that focuses on ethical
questions."
Alternative-Worlds.com
"Robert J. Sawyer has a way of taking familiar ideas, looking at them
from new angles and in greater depth than almost anybody before him,
and tying them together to create extraordinarily fresh and
thought-provoking stories. Rollback is a thoroughly
engaging story, with some of the most memorable people you'll ever
meet."
Analog Science Fiction & Fact
"Sawyer does a good job of exploring the social and moral
implications of rejuvenation technology; as often in SF, a
technical advance that seems an unalloyed blessing turns out to
carry with it a wide range of unexpected consequences.
Characteristically, Sawyer is more interested in broader
questions of morality and social responsibility than in a
fast-action yarn. The book delivers an emotionally
satisfying conclusion, with a number of surprises at the finish."
Asimov's Science Fiction
"Sawyer's investigation of rejuvenation especially difficult
for a man with the body of a 25-year-old married to an
octogenarian and of massively time-delayed communication
with aliens loads a fascinating story with difficult issues.
Don makes mistakes, yet he and Sarah are good people and
thoughtfully constructed characters. Rollback exploits two
staple sf tropes to produce a nicely executed, human-scale story."
Booklist
"This latest offering from sci-fi award collector Robert J. Sawyer
meets all the requirements of summertime reading it's light at
barely 300 pages, it's populated with likeable characters, it
engages the imagination and it's hard to put down. And it has robots.
Can it get any better than that?"
The Calgary Herald
"Sawyer's novels are always part science and part philosophical exercise,
raising questions of morality and ethics in the future that resonate in
the present. He doesn't get too heavy-handed with either the science or
the morality, which makes his books interesting for fans of all genres.
This is a good, quick-paced and thought-provoking read."
The Canadian Press
"Rollback is a wonderful novel. Don's personality and
character are presented in genuine depth and detail. Invention informs
every page, and no tourist guide or cultural nationalist would possibly
ask for one more description of Toronto, past, present, or future! The
two themes the psycho-social effects of life extension, SETI, CETI and
exobiology are woven together like the twin strands of DNA. I found
myself being out-anticipated by the author almost all the time. I have
always liked Contact (the novel more than the movie); the thrill
of reading Sagan's novel was matched by the thrill of reading
Rollback. Very, very moving. Here there is solemnity,
nobility, and poignancy: something grand."
John Robert Colombo, editor of Other Canadas
"Whenever I hear the adage that science fiction one day will
become science fact, I think of Sawyer's novels. He explores the
hard science behind some of our most sought-after advances, and
he also discusses what they'll do to our psyches and morals. ...
[In Rollback] heavy issues are wrapped up in a
story that is so poignant that I found myself in tears. I admire
Sawyer for not feeding us any easy answers, because there really
aren't any. Touching and thought-provoking,
Rollback has become one of my favorite science
fiction novels. It educates and enlightens, and it just might
make you think as well. Sawyer has written another classic."
The Davis Enterprise, Davis, California
"Thoughtful, low key, and convincing. One of Robert Sawyer's strongest
points as a writer is that his characters are always real people.
Sawyer has repeatedly shown that he can portray very dramatic situations
in an effective but unmelodramatic fashion."
Don D'Ammassa, the long-time book reviewer for
Science Fiction Chronicle
[full review online]
"Thoroughly entertaining (and accessible) science
fiction. Moves fast; one of those books you can't put down ...
truly engrossing human drama. The content and motive of the alien
communication turns out to be a great springboard for philosophical
discussions on morality and ethics, man's place in the universe, abortion,
and more; there are several stop-and-think moments. All through this,
Sawyer gives us characters that are totally realistic.
Rollback succeeds at being the kind of book that can
attract a wide audience. It's got mainstream appeal but is also a
great read for fans of thought-provoking science fiction. ***** [out of 5]"
SF Signal [full review online]
"Sawyer's most striking notion is that aliens will want to
contact other civilizations to discuss ethics and philosophy; he
has a good point that the science and mathematics usually assumed
must be too common to be worth all the trouble. Sarah and Don
are wonderfully pleasant people to be with as they work through
issues of life and death with intelligence and compassion."
The Denver Post [full review online]
"There's a good reason Robert J. Sawyer is so often compared to
Isaac Asimov. Sawyer is one of the few highly popular
contemporary SF writers carrying on the vision of what critic
John Clute calls `First SF,' and in Rollback,
Sawyer extrapolates a future we could all wish to live in, and
peoples it with generally good citizens just trying to get by.
It's a generous vision." Douglas Barbour in
The Edmonton Journal
"Powerfully real; a charming consideration of the ethics of
aging. With the gift of the rollback, Don, no longer physically
80, is able to start again a lifetime's wisdom packed in a
buff adolescent's body. What good can he do the second time
around? The sky's the limit." The Georgia Straight
"While Rollback is, on the surface, a book about reaching
out to those across the universe, it is at its heart an investigation of
our very humanity, and how relationships are a fundamental key to defining
who we are. Sawyer's crisp and accessible writing style allows for this
interweaving of the personal and the scientific. The characters feel
real, and their emotions and responses genuine. Beyond the SF trappings,
Rollback is a story about love and commitment, about
humanity at its most basic a novel to be savoured by science-fiction
and mainstream readers alike."
The Globe and Mail: Canada's National Newspaper
"Rollback is a dynamite science fiction novel that examines
some major themes. We get the big story communications with aliens
and a smaller one life extension. Both are told cleanly, intelligently
and woven together well. A wholly satisfying story."
January Magazine
[full review online]
"Above all, the author's characters bear their human
strengths and weaknesses with dignity and poise. An elegantly told story
for all libraries; highly recommended."
Library Journal (starred review, denoting
a work of exceptional merit)
[full review online]
"An early candidate for sci-fi book of the year."
Kansas City Star
"Rollback gets my vote as SF novel of the year.
A joy to read."
Jack McDevitt, author of Odyssey
"This is probably Sawyer's most character-driven story to date, and it
doesn't take away from the free flow of thoughts and ideas that we've
come to expect from a Sawyer novel. This is a terrific and worthy
entry in the Sawyer catalog. I strongly recommend you get out to your
local bookseller and buy this immediately; I enjoyed it immensely."
MT Void [full review online]
"Canadian author Sawyer once
again presents likable characters facing big ethical
dilemmas in this smoothly readable near-future SF
novel. Sawyer, who has won Hugo and Nebula awards, may
well win another major SF award with this superior
effort."
Publishers Weekly (starred review,
denoting a work of exceptional merit)
"Can love survive if one partner is restored to youth while the other
remains aged? This brilliant premise is full of tension as well as
heartbreak. Sawyer's highly emotional and original novel is a romance,
albeit one that is not often encountered. The plot combines fascinating
themes alien contact, rejuvenation and love. It's a complex story
with sympathetic and believable characters. Ethical dilemmas that may
come with future technology make this a riveting book."
Romantic Times BOOKReviews
(4½ Stars their highest rating) [full review online]
"The repercussions of the rollback surgery are genuinely surprising,
but rooted firmly in the skillfully crafted and realistic thoughts
and emotions of Don and Sarah. When the plotlines converge late in
the book, it is a reminder of why Sawyer is one of our most highly
regarded writers of speculative fiction, able to handle the demands
of the heart and the cosmos with equal skill."
Quill & Quire
[full review online]
"I highly recommend Robert J. Sawyer's Rollback.
It's a shoo-in to be short-listed for next year's major awards."
SciFiDimensions
[full review online]
"Rollback has a thoroughly engaging story line even when
it deals with ethical and moral questions waiting on the threshold
of our technological advancements. Sawyer, noted for his attention to
the development of individual characters, does it well in
Rollback too. Characters are not submerged in the deluge of
issues of cosmic scale; the human interest is kept alive throughout the
book however, Sawyer does more: he examines issues of larger
significance. Rollback is an interesting, well-told story
with beautiful characterization. The genuine attempt to discuss the
moral conundrums makes it yet another engaging book by Sawyer that
plays to the readers' intellect as well as emotion."
SFRA Review
[full review online major spoiler alert, though]
"A fascinating human drama, where joy and tragedy take human form,
rather than apocalyptic ones. All in all, it's a 'skytop' story, worth
reading by genre and mainstream readers alike."
SFRevu
[full review online]
"Sawyer is Canada's most lauded SF writer, and Rollback
has a lot of things going for it. Sawyer has come up with a
new twist on the first-contact story, a romance across the ages, a
surprisingly lovable robot, no violence and not a single villain. While
not everyone does the right thing at all times in the book, everyone
who messes up has reasons for what they do. Don is essentially a very
nice man who tries very hard to do the right thing, and it's
really easy for us to forgive him even when he slips up."
The Whitehorse Star
More Good Reading
More about Rollback
Robert J. Sawyer's awards and honors
What's a Rob Sawyer novel like?
Review index
My Very Occasional Newsletter
HOME • MENU • TOP
Copyright © 1995-2024 by Robert J. Sawyer.
|